There is a number most people with diabetes check obsessively, and a number most people barely look at. They have them the wrong way round.
What fasting sugar actually measures
A fasting glucose reading tells you how much sugar was in your blood at one moment, after roughly eight hours without food, on one particular morning.
That is genuinely useful information. It is also enormously variable, and this is where people get into trouble.
Your fasting number moves with how well you slept. It moves with whether you were stressed yesterday. It moves with what you ate the previous evening and how late you ate it. It moves with being unwell, with some medicines, and with the ordinary early-morning rise in hormones that nudges your liver into releasing glucose before you wake up.
So someone checks on Tuesday and is pleased, checks on Thursday after a bad night and is frightened, and concludes that something they did on Wednesday caused it. Usually nothing did. They are watching noise and reading it as signal.
Checking daily, for most people who are not on insulin, produces anxiety rather than information.
What HbA1c measures
HbA1c looks at something slower and much harder to fool.
Glucose in your blood attaches itself to haemoglobin inside your red blood cells. The more glucose there has been, the more of it is stuck on. Red blood cells live around three months, so measuring what proportion of them carry this attached glucose gives you an average of roughly the last eight to twelve weeks.
One bad week barely moves it. One good morning does not move it at all. It is the closest thing available to an honest summary of how the last three months actually went.
This is why your doctor asks for it and why it is the number that should carry the most weight in any decision about your treatment.
Why the two can disagree
It is entirely possible to have a reasonable fasting number and a troubling HbA1c at the same time, and this combination catches a lot of people out.
The usual explanation is what happens after meals. If your fasting glucose returns to a decent level overnight but climbs high after every meal and stays there for hours, you can spend a large part of each day at elevated levels while still waking up to a number that looks fine.
The morning reading never sees it. The HbA1c sees all of it.
The test nobody asks for
Which brings us to the third number: the post-meal reading, taken about two hours after you start eating.
In the usual progression of type 2 diabetes, post-meal glucose begins misbehaving well before fasting glucose does. It is often the earliest sign that something is changing, and it is the one almost nobody checks, because the advice everyone grows up with is to test "on an empty stomach".
If you are going to check at home at all, a post-meal reading two or three times a week after your usual biggest meal will tell you considerably more than a fasting reading every single morning. It also tells you something you can act on, because it responds to what you just ate and whether you walked afterwards.
What to actually ask for
When you next see your doctor, ask for fasting glucose and HbA1c together rather than one of them. They answer different questions and they are more useful side by side than either is alone.
Ask what your own targets are, in numbers, written down. Targets are not the same for everyone. They vary with age, how long you have had diabetes, what other conditions you have, and what medication you are on. An older person on insulin and a recently diagnosed forty-year-old should not be aiming at the same figure, and a target you read on the internet is not yours.
Then ask how often you should be testing at home, and at what times. For a great many people on tablets alone, the honest answer is far less often than they currently do.
Everything in this article is background for that conversation. None of it is a substitute for it, and no article can tell you what your numbers should be.
If you have never been tested
India has more than a hundred million people living with diabetes, and a very large proportion of them do not know it yet. People feel broadly fine for years while this is happening, because feeling fine is not the same as being clear.
If you are over thirty, if there is diabetes in your immediate family, if your waist has been quietly growing, or if you had gestational diabetes in a pregnancy, a fasting glucose and an HbA1c together are inexpensive and fast. They cost less than a box of festival mithai.
Thirty, not forty. Indian guidance sets the screening age there because diabetes arrives roughly a decade earlier in Indians than in other populations, and a lot of people who assume they have years in hand do not.
The worst outcome of getting tested is finding out early, which is the best outcome available.
Why we wrote this
We run a free channel called Diabetes Care, on WhatsApp and Telegram. It carries one small thing a day: what to eat, why it works, and what to actually ask your doctor, written for Indian homes and Indian food.
It is free, nobody calls you, and you can leave whenever you want. If you have read this far, it is probably for you.